70 homes approved for controversial marina site near Upton

First published in News
Last updated

CONTROVERSIAL plans to build up to 70 homes near Upton Marina have been given the go-ahead by a planning inspector in the face of local opposition.

The plan, submitted by Tingdene Marinas, calls for the houses to be built on land off the A4104 between the existing marina and the village of Holly Green.

Residents fear that the new development will increase the amount of traffic on the A4104, which is already busy.

The plan was thrown out by Malvern Hills District Council in October, with members of the Southern Area Development

Management Committee voting 16 to one, with one abstention, for refusal.

The councillors were following the recommendations of planning officers, who said the application should be refused due to the impact on highway safety, specifically the site's emergency access, located at the service road off the A4104, which was deemed as having a "substantial" adverse impact on road safety, particularly when flooding makes the main entrance unusable.

Residents commented that the A4104 is a "narrow twisting lane" which has seen a number of accidents, and which will become "even more dangerous" with more traffic.

Tingdene appealed the refusal, and following a public hearing last month, planning inspector David Wildsmith had allowed the application to go ahead.

In his report, Mr Wildsmith said: "I fully accept that at such times the service road and the area round it may well become very busy and congested. However, such events are infrequent and of relatively short duration."

As one of the conditions of approval, Mr Wildsmith says he applicant must install an automated bollard system to restrict use of the emergency access, that the district council must approve details of the system and that it must be in place before any of the houses are occupied, and for the lifetime of the development.

The applicant already has planning permission, approved on appeal in 2008, for 42 holiday lodges on the same site.

Comments (5)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

6:17pm Sat 7 Jun 14

citykid says...

How stupid, no doubt who ever approved this doesn't live in the area!!!!! Traffice will be horrendous , what about floods???
How stupid, no doubt who ever approved this doesn't live in the area!!!!! Traffice will be horrendous , what about floods??? citykid
  • Score: -4

7:03pm Sat 7 Jun 14

3thinker says...

Hope the Developers have including swimming lessons in their Travel Plan.
Hope the Developers have including swimming lessons in their Travel Plan. 3thinker
  • Score: -3

10:45pm Sat 7 Jun 14

Small Town says...

"Residents fear that the new development will increase the amount of traffic on the A4104, which is already busy" - It's a main A-road for goodness sake, of course it's busy!

We have A-roads built to manage high traffic levels, 70-100 houses is hardly going to be a huge impact.

Thankfully sense has served and this development, at least in part meeting local demand for housing, has been passed. The quality of the planned development is apparently sensational, the setting equally so. But of course the positive ripple effect will spread so much further than the immediate occupants, you just ask the local independent shop owners, the restaurant owners, the plumbers and the decorators, 100 new families to offer their trade to.

Exciting times ahead.
"Residents fear that the new development will increase the amount of traffic on the A4104, which is already busy" - It's a main A-road for goodness sake, of course it's busy! We have A-roads built to manage high traffic levels, 70-100 houses is hardly going to be a huge impact. Thankfully sense has served and this development, at least in part meeting local demand for housing, has been passed. The quality of the planned development is apparently sensational, the setting equally so. But of course the positive ripple effect will spread so much further than the immediate occupants, you just ask the local independent shop owners, the restaurant owners, the plumbers and the decorators, 100 new families to offer their trade to. Exciting times ahead. Small Town
  • Score: 8

10:49am Sun 8 Jun 14

anglew711 says...

Free wellies with each house?
Free wellies with each house? anglew711
  • Score: -2

9:31am Mon 9 Jun 14

thebleedingobvious says...

The new homes will not flood. Access will be possible to and from the site even in times of flood. The extra houses will no doubt add to the likelihood of seeing improvements being made to the A4104/A38 junction. The application should never have been refused in the first place. Yet another example of the inadequacies of WCC Highways and MHDC Planning Departments.
The new homes will not flood. Access will be possible to and from the site even in times of flood. The extra houses will no doubt add to the likelihood of seeing improvements being made to the A4104/A38 junction. The application should never have been refused in the first place. Yet another example of the inadequacies of WCC Highways and MHDC Planning Departments. thebleedingobvious
  • Score: 6

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree