‘Obesity just as much a problem as starvation’

Malvern Gazette: Child cruelty of parents whose kids get obese Child cruelty of parents whose kids get obese

PARENTS who let their offspring gorge themselves until they become obese are committing child cruelty, a councillor has warned.

Pat Witherspoon, a member of Worcestershire’s health overview and scrutiny committee and a former social worker, feels the ‘abuse’ is just as big an issue as a child being underfed.

“I actually took a child into care because the youngster was underweight and in many ways this is the same issue,” she said.

“To me it is child cruelty. I don’t think we should lose sight of that.”

Tackling obesity is one of the county’s top health priorities.

As reported by your Worcester News, despite a slight improvement, new figures show almost one in three children between 10 and 11 in Worcestershire are still either obese or overweight.

But Coun Marcus Hart, county cabinet member for health, does not back taking children into care because they are obese.

“That is not really my idea,” he said.

“I think we should be doing all that we can to encourage parents to take more responsibility for their children.”

He said bringing more children into care would add to the council’s financial burden, insisting: “We ought to be ensuring that we work with schools and agencies to ensure that our children eat a balanced and healthy diet.”

But Councillor David Tibbutt believes no amount of education will make a real difference to those of any age.

He believes temptation is too readily available and said if people walk into a petrol station “where chocolates are everywhere”, then nine out of 10 of them will buy something.

“We have developed over thousands of years to eat whatever food is available,” he said. “This empowerment business is nonsense. You cannot empower people when they have a built-in imperative to eat.”

Society must find a way to remove “temptations”, he said, adding: “Someone’s choice is somebody else’s compulsion.”

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

4:28pm Tue 17 Dec 13

Jabbadad says...

Any comment from Lucy Hodgson?
Any comment from Lucy Hodgson? Jabbadad

5:05am Wed 18 Dec 13

Rita Jelfs says...

Ms Witherspoon, as an ex-social worker should know that claiming a simplistic solution to a complex problem may be suitable for the 'populist' press, but is an hardly an evidence-based solution to the problem of obesity? I also doubt that a court would agree with her thoughts. Now that Ms Witherspoon is in a political position, perhaps she could show that she is capable of seeking evidence-based policy instead, that will educate ignorant or uninformed parents, rather than claiming obese children are being treated cruelly, and then going on to punish the children.
Ms Witherspoon, as an ex-social worker should know that claiming a simplistic solution to a complex problem may be suitable for the 'populist' press, but is an hardly an evidence-based solution to the problem of obesity? I also doubt that a court would agree with her thoughts. Now that Ms Witherspoon is in a political position, perhaps she could show that she is capable of seeking evidence-based policy instead, that will educate ignorant or uninformed parents, rather than claiming obese children are being treated cruelly, and then going on to punish the children. Rita Jelfs

11:09am Wed 18 Dec 13

Jabbadad says...

Rita jefs, don't know how many years experience you have, but Mrs Pat Witherspoon has over 30 yeras experince in social care work including senior positions held , and if she has been misquoted, so be it. But I would back Pat Witherspoons experience and knowlege 100%. And she is not just now in politics, but has also many years experience there as well. And although I do not always share her politics I welcome her experience and input into the committees we seem to sit on.
Rita jefs, don't know how many years experience you have, but Mrs Pat Witherspoon has over 30 yeras experince in social care work including senior positions held , and if she has been misquoted, so be it. But I would back Pat Witherspoons experience and knowlege 100%. And she is not just now in politics, but has also many years experience there as well. And although I do not always share her politics I welcome her experience and input into the committees we seem to sit on. Jabbadad

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree