Wheelies have divided council

THE controversial decision to introduce wheelie bins into Malvern may have been taken without the proper authority, a councillor has claimed.

Tony Warburton, who represents Alfrick and Leigh on Malvern Hills District Council, believes the council has acted improperly in pushing through the opinion-splitting plastic bins without councillors being asked for approval.

A switch to wheelie bins and fortnightly collections for recycling is set to take place in May after the council received £1.67 million of government funding.

Leader David Hughes and head of community services Ivor Pumfrey insist by approving the bid for funding, councillors had explicitly backed the introduction of the new scheme.

Coun Hughes has rejected Coun Warburton’s calls for full council to discuss the matter urgently, saying the council’s intentions were clear and he had checked this understanding with both the monitoring officer and council solicitor.

But Coun Warburton said he was very unhappy with that response, maintaining “such major decisions are not made by implication”.

He will continue to lobby for the matter to be aired publicly and said he would pursue it through the relevant official or legal channels if necessary.

He has told Coun Hughes: “I am surprised that you interpret the words of the relevant resolutions as “clearly setting out the council’s intention to implement” service changes.

“The words simply do not say that and no amount of twisting will make them do so.” He also slammed the suggestion that, in approving the bid for funding last year, the council had demonstrated its “full support”.

“It was approved by a majority, and a grudging one at that, following the formulation and submission of an outline bid,”

he said.

Mr Pumfrey, who is co-ordinating the roll-out of the new recycling scheme, said the funding and new system would safeguard weekly black bag collections.

“95 per cent of people have told us they highly value that,” he said.

“Not going ahead would have meant a switch to twoweekly black bag collections and we would probably have had to make other service cuts as well.”

WHEELIE BINS FACTFILE

MALVERN Hills District Council this week gave the Gazette more information about its plans to introduce wheelie bins for recycled waste.

What is going to change?

From May, the current system of collecting recycling in plastic sacks weekly will be replaced with fortnightly wheelie bin collections.

Weekly black bag collections for general waste are guaranteed for the next five years as a condition of the government funding.

Will I be getting a wheelie bin then?

Most likely, yes. The vast majority of homes will be receiving either a standard or “compact” sized wheelie bin with a small minority of hard-to-reach properties – estimated at between 17- 22 per cent of homes in the district – continuing with a sack service for recycling.

Do I have a say in the matter?

The council says it has taken great care to ensure wheelie bins will only be provided to properties where they are suitable, with members of its waste collection teams being asked for their first-hand experience of routes when decisions were made. It acknowledges that some properties will have been a “judgement call” and says that, while it cannot sanction a “free for all”, it is happy to have discussions.

When will I know what to expect?

Very soon. The council will be writing to every household next week letting them know the recycling method that has been selected for them. A second letter will be sent at the start of March with details of when bins, if required, will be delivered.

What if I’m not strong enough to be pushing a wheelie bin around?

The council will continue to offer its “assisted collection service”, already used by about 1,000 people. Anyone who has mobility issues and is unable to deal with a wheelie bin should call the Worcestershire Hub on 01684 862151 for assistance.

Anything else I should know?

The council will be introducing a new “customer alert” service alongside the new recycling arrangements. This will allow residents to sign up for alerts and warnings of any service disruptions by text or email.

Comments(9)

THE FACTS says...
7:19pm Fri 25 Jan 13

Thanks for responding to my request for the full picture.

This seems to make provision for almost everyones circumstances and so there is no issue.

If there is a problem it seems arrangements can be contracted with the council.

So we have been wasting time on this matter... time we could have saved had we had this information at teh time the decision was announced.

The council need to understand how to communicate in a timely manner with the tax payer.... I think is the lesson.

Casmal says...
1:02pm Sat 26 Jan 13

So, you think it is that simple? Actually the figure of homes needing to continue with the bags was 25% at the last count. Doubtless the number of people needing assistance will rise and this will add to the cost, although doubtless many who need the help will not ask, for a variety of reasons. And who decides whether they get the help or not? And what about those for whom the judgement call is not appropriate? Will the officers be playing God?

And we still have no answers as to why the council is happy to implement a system that was trialled some years ago and shown not to work.

Then there is the issue of legislation. The EU regulations require all collections to be single stream by 2015, not comingled, as comingling results in much poorer quality of recycling, with less being recycled and more going to landfill due to contamination. Have a look at the Directive and Guidance, as well as the WRAP.org.uk website. WRAP was set and is funded by the EU and the four govt. of the UK. So where will that leave Malvern? At risk of fines?

And finally, if what Cllr Warburton is reported to have said is correct, then once again vital information has been kept from Councillors by Officers and democracy has been sidestepped.

When you have read the appropriate legislation, as well as the report to Council last July, which seems not to be in line with the EU directive, I would be happy to hear your views.

Nathan Barley says...
10:59pm Sat 26 Jan 13

Haven't we all got better things to worry about than which councillor is "playing God" with the bins?

This plan saves money and also guarantees my weekly bin bag collection which gets the dismembered body parts of the dead hookers out of my flat in good time. Any longer and the smell becomes overpowering.

All in all, a WHEELIE good idea.

sarah and her chickens says...
1:49pm Sun 27 Jan 13

Very funny Nathan, however this will cost the taxpayer £1.67 million pounds in three years and then leave a funding shortfall !
Then we will get fortnightly collections from two wheelie bins ! So the bodies really will smell.
9000 homes will not get bins. So we wil stil be buying sacks and delivering them and paying for the extra staff needed to drag all those bins about.
Having just had the snow those that miss a collection wil have to wait a month. Also true if you forget to put your wheelie out !
If this council was really thinking about the residents it would have looked beyond the three years grant money and found Very funny Nathan, however this will cost the taxpayer £1.67 million pounds in three years and then leave a funding shortfall !
Then we will get fortnightly collections from two wheelie bins ! So the bodies really will smell.
9000 homes will not get bins. So we wil stil be buying sacks and delivering them and paying for the extra staff needed to drag all those bins about.
Having just had the snow those that miss a collection wil have to wait a month. Also true if you forget to put your wheelie out !
If this council was really thinking about the residents it would have looked beyond the three years grant money and found asustainable and environmentally friendly way of tackling recycling it would have found a financially sustainable and environmentally friendly way of tackling recycling. Not just chuck it all in a wheelie bin and then let 20% of it end up in landfill.
Please Councillors let this be the last time you allow the officers to work as dictatorship !

sarah and her chickens says...
1:58pm Sun 27 Jan 13

That's odd! Malvern gazette online doing things in duplicate

Casmal says...
4:10pm Sun 27 Jan 13

It was not the Councillors I was suggesting were playimg or would play God.

What we do need to worry about is the deocratic process and whether those that are elected to make the decisions are given sufficient information with which to make them affectively.

sarah and her chickens says...
9:33am Mon 28 Jan 13

Or even if those that we have elected can be bothered to find out the information to give them enough of an understanding to vote on their own merit rather than simply do s they are told by the portfolio holder, the council leader and the relevant officer.
The final say in the bid was down to those three alone. The council were given no option on voting on anything other than bins.it seems they were then told by the leader who had chosen wheelie bins that they had to vote for them. Is that democracy in action.or is that a dictatorship

Casmal says...
10:17am Mon 28 Jan 13

Quite. And it's not the first time that this has happened. Too often issues are brought to Council at the last minute and Councillors are told there is no time for alternative options to be explored.

PS Apologies for the spelling mistake. I should have spelt more effectively!

sarah and her chickens says...
12:45pm Tue 29 Jan 13

Just read in the bid that they are looking at sharing services with Herefordshire to save on operational costs.
So to do that they must be going to privatise the refuse and recycling service to FOCSA.
Lots of blacked out text though !! Always suspicious when they have to do that in a public document hhhmmmm

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree